| Year |
Chief |
| 2009 |
Kevin Maloney |
| 2008 |
Kevin Maloney |
| 2006 |
Ken Nelson |
| 2005 |
Kevin Maloney |
| 2001 |
Robert Sheard |
| 2000 |
Robert Hill |
| 1999 |
Gary Wagner |
| 1998 |
Robert Sheard |
| 1995 |
Gary Wagner |
| 1993 |
Scott Fisher |
| 1992 |
Neal Nelson |
| 1989 |
Scott Fisher |
| 1987 |
William Cirone |
| 1986 |
Gerald Sheard |
| 1983 |
Arthur Deden |
| 1982 |
Edmund Barry |
| 1980 |
Robert Katchen |
| 1979 |
Edmund Barry |
| 1977 |
Charles Brown |
| 1976 |
Edmund Barry |
| 1973 |
Robert McLaughlin |
| 1971 |
Thomas Philhower |
| 1968 |
George Wagner |
| 1966 |
George MacConnell |
| 1965 |
Thomas Philhower |
| 1963 |
Elmer VanDermark |
| 1962 |
George Smith |
| 1960 |
Andrew Kovach |
| 1959 |
John Brown |
| 1954 |
Andrew Kovach |
| 1951 |
Ray DeGraw |
| 1950 |
Herbert Wagner |
| 1949 |
Ray DeGraw |
| 1946 |
Howard Smith |
| 1943 |
Elmer Dilley |
| 1942 |
Howard Smith |
| 1941 |
Ray DeGraw |
| 1939 |
Edward Brown |
| 1937 |
Dallas Batson |
| 1935 |
Andrew Brown |
| 1934 |
George Todd |
| 1934 |
Fred Klenke |
| 1933 |
Edward Trinner |
| 1932 |
Robert Fennimore |
| 1931 |
Lewis Schulz |
